Trillium Wealth
Guide

What Is a Fiduciary Financial Advisor?

The word “fiduciary” gets used a lot in financial advertising. Here is what it means in law, where it stops, and how to confirm it before you hire anyone.

The short answer

A fiduciary financial advisor is legally required to act in your best interest, put your interests ahead of their own, and disclose conflicts of interest. Registered investment advisers owe this duty for the whole advisory relationship. You can check any advisor's registration and disclosures for free at adviserinfo.sec.gov and FINRA BrokerCheck.

Key takeaways

  • “Financial advisor” is a general title. “Fiduciary” describes a legal duty, and not everyone who gives financial advice owes it in the same way.
  • Registered investment advisers owe a fiduciary duty of care and loyalty under federal law. Broker-dealers follow Regulation Best Interest when recommending to retail customers.
  • Fiduciary does not mean conflict-free. It means conflicts must be disclosed and managed, so read the firm's Form CRS and Form ADV.
  • Every compensation model, including percentage-of-assets fees, creates some incentive. Ask how your advisor is paid and what that encourages.
  • Verify before you hire: SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure, FINRA BrokerCheck and Investor.gov/CRS are free.

What does “fiduciary” mean for a financial advisor?

A fiduciary is someone legally bound to act in another person's best interest. For an investment adviser, that means giving advice that serves you, not the firm, and telling you about anything that could tempt the adviser to do otherwise.

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission describes an investment adviser's fiduciary duty as two parts in its 2019 interpretation of the standard of conduct for investment advisers:

  • Duty of care. Advice must be in your best interest based on a reasonable understanding of your goals and situation. It includes seeking best execution on trades and monitoring at a frequency that fits the relationship you agreed to.
  • Duty of loyalty. The adviser may not put its own interests ahead of yours, and must fully and fairly disclose material facts and conflicts of interest so you can give informed consent.

The SEC states that this duty follows the entire relationship, shaped by its scope, and cannot be waived. In plain terms, the adviser is on your side of the table for the services it has agreed to provide.

How is the fiduciary standard different from the suitability standard?

The short version: a fiduciary adviser must act in your best interest throughout the relationship, while a broker's obligations attach mainly at the moment a recommendation is made.

For decades, brokers were held to a suitability standard. Under FINRA Rule 2111, a recommendation must be suitable for the customer based on their investment profile. A suitable recommendation is not necessarily the lowest-cost or most appropriate option available.

Since June 30, 2020, broker-dealers making recommendations to retail customers must also follow the SEC's Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI). It requires a broker to act in the retail customer's best interest at the time of the recommendation, without putting the firm's interest first, and adds disclosure, care, conflict-of-interest and compliance obligations. FINRA's Reg BI overview explains how firms apply it.

Reg BI raised the bar, but it is not identical to an adviser's fiduciary duty. The practical differences to ask about:

  • Timing. Reg BI applies when a recommendation is made. An adviser's duty applies across the advisory relationship.
  • Monitoring. A broker generally has no ongoing duty to monitor your account unless agreed. An adviser providing ongoing management typically does.
  • Pay. Brokers are usually paid per transaction. Advisers are usually paid an ongoing fee.

What is the difference between an RIA and a broker-dealer?

A registered investment adviser (RIA) is a firm paid to give investment advice and is registered with the SEC or a state. A broker-dealer buys and sells securities for customers, is registered with the SEC and is generally a member of FINRA.

Many professionals are “dually registered,” meaning they can act as an investment adviser representative on some accounts and as a registered representative of a broker-dealer on others. That is legal and common, but it means the standard can change from one account or one recommendation to the next. Ask which role your advisor is acting in for each account.

Two other rule sets can come into play. The CFP Board Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct requires CFP® professionals to act as fiduciaries when providing financial advice to a client. And advice on workplace retirement plans and IRAs can be subject to Department of Labor rules under ERISA and the tax code; the scope of those rules has changed through rulemaking and litigation over the years, so check the Employee Benefits Security Administration for the current position.

How can you verify whether an advisor is a fiduciary?

Start with public records, then confirm in writing. Registration tells you which standard applies, and the disclosure documents tell you how the firm is paid and where its conflicts sit.

  1. Search the firm and the person. The SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site (adviserinfo.sec.gov) lists registered advisers and their representatives. FINRA BrokerCheck covers brokers and also shows adviser information. Investor.gov/CRS searches both. Look at registrations, employment history and any disciplinary disclosures.
  2. Read Form CRS. The client relationship summary is a short, plain-language document that advisers and brokers serving retail investors must provide. It covers services, fees, conflicts and disciplinary history, and ends with suggested questions. You can read Trillium Wealth's Form CRS as an example of the format.
  3. Read Form ADV Part 2. The Form ADV brochure (Part 2A) explains the firm's services, fees, conflicts and investment approach in detail. The brochure supplement (Part 2B) covers the individual advisor's background.
  4. Get it in writing. Ask the advisor to confirm, in the advisory agreement or a letter, that they act as a fiduciary for all of the accounts and services they provide to you.

How do fees create conflicts of interest?

Every way of paying for advice creates some incentive. A fiduciary is expected to disclose those incentives and manage them, not to pretend they do not exist.

How the advisor is paidWhat it can encourage
Commissions on productsRecommending products that pay more, or trading more often
Percentage of assets managedKeeping money in managed accounts rather than paying down debt, buying property or funding a business
Flat or retainer feeLess incentive tied to your balances, but you pay whether or not you use the service much in a given year
Hourly feeLower ongoing cost, but less ongoing monitoring unless you keep paying for time
Revenue sharing, proprietary funds or affiliate referralsFavoring the firm's own products or affiliated businesses

“Fee-only” describes compensation (the advisor takes no commissions). “Fee-based” usually means fees plus some commissions. Neither label, on its own, tells you whether a fiduciary duty applies to everything the person does. The SEC's investor guide to investment advisers is a useful neutral primer.

What questions should you ask a fiduciary advisor?

Good questions are specific and invite a written answer. These come from the SEC's Form CRS conversation starters and common due diligence practice:

  • Are you a fiduciary for every account and every recommendation you make to me?
  • How are you and your firm paid, and what would I pay in total in a typical year, including fund expenses and transaction costs?
  • What conflicts of interest do you have, and how do you manage them?
  • Do you or your firm earn anything from the products you recommend, including insurance?
  • Who holds my money? (It should be an independent custodian that sends statements directly to you.)
  • Do you or your firm have any legal or disciplinary history?
  • What are your licenses, credentials and relevant experience, and what do they mean?

For more on interviewing advisors, see our guide on how to choose a financial advisor.

Where does Trillium Wealth fit?

Trillium Wealth, LLC is registered with the SEC as an investment adviser. Its Form CRS states that when it manages your assets it acts as a fiduciary, which means it must prudently take care of your money and at all times act for your benefit.

The same document describes how Trillium is paid and where its conflicts are. Investment management fees are either a percentage of assets under management or a fixed annual fee, at the client's election. Trillium does not offer proprietary products or wrap fee programs, and it does not impose an account minimum. It also discloses that some of its financial professionals are licensed insurance agents who earn commissions on insurance they implement, and that certain owners and affiliates are connected to Trillium Tax, LLC, Trillium Insurance, LLC and Trillium Business Advisory, LLC. Clients are under no obligation to use those affiliates.

That is the kind of disclosure you should expect from any fiduciary firm. Read it, ask about it, and decide whether the arrangement works for you. You can learn more about our investment management approach, read our FAQ, or see how we work with clients.

This guide is for educational purposes and is not individualized tax, legal or investment advice.

Common Questions

Frequently asked questions

Are all financial advisors fiduciaries?

No. “Financial advisor” is a general title that many kinds of professionals use. Registered investment advisers owe a fiduciary duty under federal law, broker-dealers follow Regulation Best Interest when recommending to retail customers, and insurance agents follow insurance rules that vary by state. Ask which standard applies to each account.

Is a CFP professional always a fiduciary?

The CFP Board's Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct requires CFP professionals to act as fiduciaries when providing financial advice to a client. The CFP Board enforces that standard. Legal duties still depend on how the person is registered, so confirm both.

Does fiduciary mean an advisor has no conflicts of interest?

No. Fiduciary advisers can have conflicts, such as fees tied to assets or commissions on insurance. The duty requires those conflicts to be disclosed and managed so you can give informed consent. Form CRS and Form ADV Part 2A list them.

How do I check whether an advisor is registered?

Search the person and the firm on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site (adviserinfo.sec.gov), FINRA BrokerCheck, or Investor.gov/CRS. These free tools show registrations, employment history and any disciplinary disclosures.

Is a fee-only advisor the same as a fiduciary?

Not exactly. Fee-only describes how an advisor is paid: fees from clients and no commissions. Fiduciary describes a legal duty. Many fee-only advisers are also registered investment advisers with a fiduciary duty, but you should confirm both separately.

Next step

Talk to an advisor

Have questions about how fiduciary advice would work for your situation? Start with a short, no-obligation conversation with a Trillium advisor.

Talk to an Advisor