GDP Revisions, Rare Earth Tensions, and What They Signal
October 17, 2025 · Steve Laska, Matt Gomoll · 30 min

GDP Revisions, Rare Earth Tensions, and What They Signal
October 17, 2025 · 30 min
Episode summary
In this mid-October 2025 episode of Plain Talk, Steve Laska and Matt Gomoll start with a quick update on the government shutdown and China's surprise move to withhold rare earth minerals. Matt explains that China's position comes from its willingness to mine and process these materials, which he calls dirty work, rather than from being the only place they exist. He says both countries have leverage and hopes talks planned in South Korea lead to progress.
Answering a client question, Matt walks through a revision to GDP from 3.3% up to 3.8%. He explains that revisions happen as better data arrives, that heavy importing ahead of tariffs pulled first-quarter GDP negative, and that GDP adds consumption, investment, government spending, and exports minus imports. Steve stresses that growth near 4% is massive for an economy of about 30 trillion dollars. Matt notes government spending is about 17% of GDP and that the shutdown will likely lower this quarter's number.
Looking ahead, Matt argues companies will spend more to build secure supply chains closer to home, and that AI could raise productivity once businesses reorganize around it, as factories did with electricity. Steve, who calls himself optimistic, says he could see temporary pullbacks but sees major opportunity over the next decade. Matt closes by saying the long term is about earnings growth, while trade headlines can move markets in the near term.
Key takeaways
- Matt Gomoll said rare earths exist in many places, including Ukraine, Africa and the western U.S., but China dominates because it has committed to the dirty work of mining and processing them.
- Matt explained that a GDP revision from 3.3% to 3.8% reflects better data arriving after the first estimate, which is common for government statistics.
- Matt said first-quarter 2025 GDP was negative largely because businesses imported heavily to get ahead of tariffs, and imports subtract from GDP.
- Steve Laska argued that growth near 4% is massive on an economy of roughly 30 trillion dollars, so historical comparisons need context.
- Matt said government spending is about 17% of GDP and that the shutdown will likely make this quarter's GDP a little lower, with some of it made up later.
- Matt argued that more companies will invest in secure supply chains in or near the U.S. after learning the lessons of COVID.
- Matt compared AI to electricity, saying big productivity gains came only after factories reorganized around the new technology, and he expects a similar lag with AI.
Questions this episode answers
Why was GDP revised up from 3.3% to 3.8%?
In October 2025, Matt Gomoll explained that GDP revisions are common because more complete data arrives a month or two after the first estimate. He said second-quarter GDP was revised from 3.3% up to 3.8%, after a negative first quarter driven by heavy importing ahead of tariffs. Steve Laska added that a move of that size is very large for an economy of about 30 trillion dollars.
How is GDP calculated?
Matt Gomoll described GDP as an attempt to measure all goods and services produced within U.S. borders. He listed its parts as household consumption, business investment, government consumption and investment, and exports minus imports. He noted that when imports far exceed exports, that last component pulls the total down.
Why does China control rare earth minerals?
Matt Gomoll said in October 2025 that rare earths are found in many places, including Ukraine, Africa, the western U.S. and Alaska, but China committed to mining and processing them, which he described as very dirty work. He said U.S. policy was long content to import the finished product, and the downside of not controlling supply is now clear. Steve Laska noted China tends to plan over much longer time frames than the U.S.
Will AI increase economic growth?
Matt Gomoll relayed a bullish view from investor Cathie Wood that GDP growth could reach 7% thanks to robotics, energy storage and AI, while cautioning that 7% may be too aggressive. His own point was that several technologies are likely to increase productivity, but, as with electricity, gains may lag until businesses reorganize around them. Steve Laska said he expects AI to create major opportunities over the next decade.
Plain Talk reflects the views of the speakers as of the recording date and is provided for informational purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security or a guarantee of future results. Market conditions change; talk with your advisor before acting on anything discussed.
Full transcriptRead the full conversation
Automatically transcribed from the episode audio; may contain minor errors. Select a timestamp to play from that point.
Once again, welcome to Trillium Wealth Plain Talk. I'm here as always with my partner Matt Gomoll and uh we try to talk about things that are timely and happening right now. And so Matt, there are a couple things I think we want to touch on very very quickly. Um you know, first just let's spend a minute on the government shutdown. It's still going and uh we said last time that that might be something. I don't know that there's any big things to be talking about, but it's still going on. >> Yeah, it's still out there. Uh neither side has conceded enough yet. Um so it's still kind of hanging out there. President Trump did just pull a few levers to to uh get troops paid uh which was a good bargaining chip uh for Democrats. And so he kind of found a workaround for that. We'll see what the next thing that needs to happen to get some concessions. Uh but yeah, I think maybe another week, two weeks. Hopefully it doesn't drag out into November.
>> Well, last time in the Trump administration, the shut there was a shutdown that lasted 35 days. So, there's there's definitely some stick tuitiveness and he seems to have more power than he did last time, you know, on these things. But as I keep saying that he he's a guy that let you know he loves to be loved and so I I think even he'll only let it go on um so long. I will say that the military pay thing you and I spoke about it this week. It's kind of like a you know I don't know who's pulling all the strings. It's kind of a brilliant maneuver, right? like it's probably illegal and you're not supposed to do it, but you know who's going to politically stand up and say I want to take you to court to not pay the troops. I I don't know who's going to do that. It might be some smaller congressman or senator, but I don't think the powers that be are going to get in the middle of that fight. So, it was um it was it's pretty unique on pulling that off.
>> Yeah, it was a new technique. We again, you're right. I don't know if it's, >> you know, it's it's Congress's job to uh uh appropriate money >> and to have the executive re, you know, pull money from one place to another legality might be questionable, but they did it and troops are going to get paid. >> So that should move things forward as far as like, okay, this is not a an issue. We're gonna hold up. Let's move on to just opening the government. >> All right. Right. So, another quick topic we want to talk about because I don't think there's a ton of, you know, noise around this either yet or or I'd say like things that we can get to out of this. But, um, you know, the big kind of a surprise thing from China like I think everybody was really thrown off by this thinking that the China US relationships are going on fine and then kind of out of nowhere we're going to re, you know, withhold rare earth minerals for you. And, you know, that's twofold. I mean, it certainly affects things like chip manufacturing, but as you know better than most, you know, the effect of that on on defense um is pretty significant.
>> Yeah, it's it it was one of those things where all of a sudden things escalated kind of last week um which which the market responded to when Trump said he was going to retaliate with huge I mean like 100% tariffs. So that really escalated things into going into the weekend. Since then, it's pulled back a little bit where he's made some statements saying we don't really want to, you know, derail this relationship and we don't want to throw each of our countries into disarray. So the markets responded positively to that and so we're kind of back on a better track. But yeah, there's there's been this tit fortat between both sides. They both have leverage. China has rare earth minerals. Absolutely. Those are critical to defense. Um I just saw something about the Department of Defense trying to buy a stockpile of I don't know which metal it was, but they need this stuff.
And they're like, "Okay, well, we're just going to get our hands on it and put it in a warehouse and use it, you know, give it to our suppliers who need to build the F-35 and the whatever other things." Because it's used in all these different uh high-tech pieces of equipment. Uh the US has tariffs. We have access to our market. Um we have our US dollar. We have a lot of things that we also use. So we're at a point where we each have leverage. Hopefully they calm things down, get to a point of talking. Uh apparently they're supposed to to meet later this month at a conference in South Korea. So hopefully that's some progress and maybe you'll see another delay of tariffs. Right. So, there's there's all these different dates of tariffs are supposed to start here or there. Hopefully, uh, as President Trump is negotiating and sees that they're making progress, some of those November tariffs won't turn on.
>> Yeah, I I'm not totally surprised. I I think um, you know, from a logic standpoint, it's a little bit of a response as you know, the the Chinese are known for looking at things in much longer pictures. you know, they don't have elections, so they think that a 25-y year plan is a short plan. Um, a 100red-year plan is a is an appropriate plan. Here in the US, we turn over our legislature every two years. And so, we've kind of gotten into two-year plans, but >> I think after some pragmatism, they're probably sitting there saying, "We understand that you want to, you know, lower your reliance on China. we're not happy about you eliminating it and we need to do stuff that, you know, they're pretty smart on knowing there's other places where rarest minerals can come from. Um the Ukraine, right? They that's part of the deal that Trump signed there. So I'm not um not totally surprised.
>> Yeah, they're the it's not like China is the only place on earth who has these things. Their unique position is they really committed to number one dig them out of the ground, which is very dirty. Uh, and number two, process them, which is also really dirty. So, there are rare earths in Ukraine. There's rare earths in and all over Africa. There's rare earths out west and in Alaska. So, >> and in Arkansas, I heard. >> Yeah. So, like deposits there. Yeah. >> Yeah. It's just so messy, right? So, for a long time, the US policy has just been uh we'll let you do that in your country. We don't wanna we don't want to take the the climate, you know, not necessarily even climate, but just like uh ecosystem hit to having a giant mine digging stuff out of the ground in Arkansas, it's it's messy. And so digging them up, processing them, it's just a dirty business. So to the extent we could import that, make that somebody else's problem way overseas, and we'll just import the product, great, we win.
Well, the problem is when we no longer control that supply, we're starting to realize the the downside, right? There there is a downside to being relying on other people for these materials and they are they're a just a huge bargaining chip with any country who wants to negotiate with us. They're they're a critical item and until you know that gets into um you know material science and and phys like physical things of like how do we actually produce this battery with different materials because we don't have enough lithium or whatever right that it's a whole different realm which you know I do expect advances to make progress on but still right where we're at today we are relying on the thing you know we've invented certain technologies and they're relying on certain materials and those are coming from certain suppliers. >> So Matt, we we'll probably get back on those topics again over the next few weeks as as they show themselves a little bit more and and I'm sure they will. I mean, there are certainly two things that Well, hopefully the government shutdown could go away any day. We don't know about that. But but the rarer thing is is I think a long-term thing that we need to look at.
But how about you know what we talked about last time is we we did take viewer feedback and there were questions on GDP and so um I know that you're prepared to talk a little bit about that today. So give us kind of the insights on the questions that was asked or were asked from our uh uh one of our clients. >> Yeah. So I think the uh the question came up because there was a pretty sizable revision to GDP and it was from 3.3% up to 3.8%. And you say wow that sounds like a big number. Um this is you know any any government statistics we see this happen. There are revisions to the jobs data, um, revisions to, you know, the economic growth, all these things. And it just has to do with more data became clear and we got better information a month or two after it was released, right? So you you put out what you have uh the first month of the quarter for example and then by the second month of the quarter you get updated you know data points from looking backwards obviously and you just say oh you know we missed that part uh it didn't come in yet now we've got it now we're going to revise it upwards or downwards so in the case of yeah we we revised GDP up from 3.3 to 3.8 eight. That was a big number.
Um, so kind of putting this thing in context, GDP Q1 was negative. It was negative. A lot of that, uh, and I'll get into a little bit of the mechanics of how GDP is calculated. We had a ton of imports. We've already talked about this before. Everybody was importing in Q1 to frontr run the tariffs. They were like, "Okay, Trump just got in office. Something's going to happen. we're going to import just so much stuff so that we uh beat the the tariff deadline and and we can get it in there cheap and then you know retailers are stocking up, everybody's stocking up. Well, that turned into a detractor of GDP um based on the way that the the number is calculated. So that was down and then Q3 or Q2 sorry was 3.3 moved up to 3.8. Um, so all this stuff it's kind of like what does it all mean? You know, we just see these year-over-year uh growth numbers and that's kind you know generally it's you know what is what is GDP growing from Q2 last year to through Q2 this year is kind of what we're doing with this stuff. Uh so the GDP it's trying to calculate like what all was produced goods and services within our borders this year right and that's why imports are excluded we don't something that was produced overseas and then shipped here we don't want to necessarily calculate as something that we produced so it is got it has a couple components there's consumption by households right I go buy something at Best Buy or Walmart or Amazon that is me consuming. There's investments so businesses uh stocking up on inventories, capital investment into their business, government consumption and investment.
And then the last part is exports minus imports. So you can see if we're taking exports minus imports and whatever that net number is, we're adding it to these other numbers. That's where you get a huge impact from a lot more imports than exports. We're going to have a detractor on that number. It'll it'll draw against the the GDP calculation a little bit. So that's kind of how we uh look at the big picture of what's all put into the the calculation and it spits out a number that is just the total number that uh I think today our GDP is last year was 29 trillion uh I think today it's up to 30 trillion um and so yeah 30.48 48 trillion dollar. That's the GDP number in nominal terms.
And then what we care about is that change, right? That change. What what what it was was it last year at this time? What is it this year? Do a calculation on the percent change is basically what's going on there. >> I think there's a danger to it, right? And I think what people forget when and you just gave a a great explanation but it is why like it's so big now and historically what would move things and that's the problem with sometimes just looking at historical data. So people like ah you know 2% isn't that big. Well, and on the size of our economy, it's massive. And getting close to 4% is absolutely massive, right? And so, we set expectations. And again, we make decisions based on numbers. >> Um, it's why, you know, Matt, you work with me every day. I hate calendar years and I hate calendar quarters because they're arbitrary, right? I And we're making decisions based on bad data. And we may be making decisions on times forgetting that our economy is so big that the days of you know there were some times I think back in the Reagan era where they had these like 7% quarters right that would be almost ridiculous right now to you know to do that our economy I don't know what it was but I I bet it was a third of the size it is now even during that time you know 40 years ago. So it's meaningful and 3.3 to 3.8 eight is a gigantic number.
>> Yeah. >> I mean like you said on on a 30 trillion dollar economy it's absolutely massive. >> Yeah. It it is um one of the things so I think part of the question that we received also was are there going to be changes to the GDP calculation like what you know there has been uh talk from the the Trump administration about trying to exclude the government number right so the government number you know you could spend a whole bunch more money make GDP look better take credit for that and then say wow look at the strong economy we have. And in reality, you're just spending a bunch of extra government dollars on debt. So that's not happening yet. So government numbers are still included. But it just kind of gets to the point that it is part of it. Government spending can be not necessarily going towards productive things, right? Not every dollar the government spend is going towards like building infrastructure that is going to help grow the economy. Some of it's not very productive spending that they do.
And so to the extent that that juices the GDP number a little bit, yeah, that's a that's a factor. Uh I would say yeah, during this government shutdown, do we expect GDP like to be a little lower? Yeah, the government's literally not spending some money right now. So if we looked at this quarter's GDP, it's probably going to be a little low. Uh will it be made up for the next time when the government reopens? Yeah, probably. Right? Like the government will just speed up the spending that they didn't do in October. Uh so it all kind of balances out but it's you know that's a factor what the government does. We do I do feel like we're getting into an era where we need to maybe curb government spending just because we have so much debt. So will that be a drag on the government's contribution to GDP? Yeah, it might. Right now I think the number was it's it represents 17% of our GDP number. Will that come down in the future? Yeah, maybe. I mean, it'd be very reasonable that it does.
>> I think there were some moves, you know, made on before the so-called big beautiful bill, you know, on tax laws and all in the last Trump administration. And we're missing something now, you know, as a guy that um, you know, went to college in the 80s and took, you know, economics classes back then. There's what's called the GNP versus the GDP. And the gross national product takes on things that are just made by Americans anywhere in the world or made by American companies anywhere in the world. >> Right? >> And when those tax laws changed and those big companies started repatriating dollars back to the US um because the tax laws were out of control, the corporate tax law. So what you had is a lot of countries making money in other countries and leaving it in that other country. I think a lot of what we're seeing right now, Matt, where we've continued to have this economy that doesn't seem to be slowing down. Even when you see the news, oh, it's slowing down. Doesn't seem to be. You know, I I fly a lot and, you know, airports are packed and things seem to be going very well out there. I think that change also has a bigger effect on our economy than it than it was for a number of years.
Now we're producing or making money in these other countries and the big boys and big girls you know the Apples and the Microsofts and the you know many different companies out there are bringing that money back to the country. So it is having an effect here. And if if people are wondering when when Apple says to President Trump, you know, we're going to build more stuff here, they have more money now that they they're willing to bring back. So, I I think we're going to see some some great byproducts and and what typically happens and we forget we're and it's worse now. You know, we're really a slave to whatever we're seeing on TV now. It's a huge economy and these things still move slower than people think and the effects of things that happened even six years ago on tax laws start to have an effect now. They didn't necessarily have the effect back then, right? Because they were still bonusing people the right way. They were still doing certain things. But the money they have to come back here and spend the money they have on things like research and development. I saw Larry Fink from uh BlackRock speaking today and um you know these are things we forget about like you know everybody's talking about the AI boom and the and the lack of jobs and what'll happen then but it's a long way till we get there. You and I have talked about the power it takes, the computer p uh uh power, the just electrical power.
Trillions of dollars of expenditures have to happen in the United States for these things to work. Trillions of dollars have to spend happen in other countries, too. But at the end of the day, we don't have robots, you know, walking around building data centers yet. And that's that's a long way off. So, there's a lot of good things on the horizon. And you and I have talked before. I just don't see, you know, I I don't want to, you know, jinx us or, you know, or think about like what could go wrong, but I'm looking at a lot of things right now and there's too many things that make me say >> I can see some temporary slowdowns. I can see like weeding the garden, so to speak, and you know, a 15% quick pullback in the market that rebounds very quickly. But with all the things that are going on right now and and things like that AI revolution that everybody's afraid of, it's also going to create at least for the next decade.
I don't know what happens after that, but for the next decade, some just ridiculous opportunities for for things that that does expand the GDP by the way when we start building things here, you know. >> Yep. Yeah. And there there's kind of two things that come to mind with what you're saying. So one is we're entering an era where companies around the world have gotten to as efficient as possible supply chains which means you have as few factories as possible to produce just the number of things that you need. There's not a lot of excess capacity. What we realized starting with COVID of saying wow our we can't even get the materials we need from China. we can't get, you know, medicines or we can't get protective equipment or whatever it was because there's not a trade war just like a literal shutdown of ports and shipping. So, to me, it hasn't fully played out yet. It did, you know, some of the uh the stimulus or not necessary stimulus, but the spending bills that uh under Biden were to say, "Yeah, I'll give you credit. Uh we want to invest in onoring stuff." So, that was already underway with the infrastructure act.
Um, it's going to continue. We're going to see more spending because people realize that the most efficient supply chain possible isn't necessarily a secure supply chain. And so, just on that basis alone, we should have more spending, more production in the US or right near us. The second part is yeah the AI what what comes of AI what comes of all this this technological innovation that's occurring right now uh I was actually listening to a podcast with Cathie Wood so she's a a very famous investor runs uh several investment funds very bullish on innovation right so she's she's on the kind of extreme end of I believe in innovation and and uh >> I I think one of her funds is named like the innovation fund yeah she's pretty big on it.
>> Very big on it. >> What she was saying, she was looking back at GDP and I was like, "Oh, this is perfect. We're going to talk about this tomorrow." >> GDP prior to electricity was about 6% per year, right? So, she was like, "Yeah, 400 years of economic data about 6% growth every single year. Slow." Then electricity happened and in the following 125 years since then we've had about 3% GDP growth. So she looked at it and she said, "Okay, this major technological change took us 5x from 6 to 3% GDP growth per year. That's massive. What is it?" And so she looked forward and and this is a very you know aggressive stance but she said it's not unreasonable if we were to hit 7% GDP growth in the coming years due to she said robotics energy storage versus batteries and AI and she was like hey that's only doubling roughly doubling our GDP growth instead of 5x which I just told you about under electricity's change. um who knows 7% maybe that's too aggressive. The point still stands there are several things going on right now technologically that are going to lead to increased productivity which are going to expand our GDP. Um, important to remember when electricity was is invented and it started to get adopted in factories, the it wasn't until the factory redid itself, reorganized itself around electricity that you saw productivity gains. Before that, you'd have all these little stations with beltrun, you know, machines or whatever. uh and if you just tried to electrify that machine, you didn't get much productivity growth. But when you realized, oh, I can build this whole thing like scrap the whole design and start from I have electricity for every stage of this. That's where we got that mass production. Henry Ford and many of the you know the um you know systems he built with >> you know car production. That's so I kind of feel like we're right there where we're starting to use AI. We're kind of adopting these things. It's not head major productivity growth where we're seeing it, you know, the the younger generation who's internalize this stuff and makes it part of their daily life. They're more productive than a 40 or 50 year old trying to implement AI in their life. And you know, frankly, businesses look more like a 40 or 50y old running it. So that's why you aren't getting the productivity yet. Give it a couple years and we're going to see it take off.
>> Yeah. And I think, you know, this topic will rare up with us again without a doubt. Um but look, there's some I'm going to point out some significant positives, right? So production is just that. And we have an aging workforce. Like I'm in the smallest generation as a Gen X guy, right? This is the this is the smallest generation. And and what happens is we've worried about what we're producing and it's a it's a double-edged sword, right? There's you we're worried about population growth using the planet's resources. Um but you need population growth for productivity. And what I would say, you know, that look, this could be nirvana um or a utopia that may a utopian existence that may not exist, but most of the world doesn't look like the United States today. Meaning all of the comforts that we have, right? All of the things that we consume. So there's a lot more that could be consumed right now worldwide as these things happened. And we could be a leader in that. And there's a, you know, when I look Matt in our own firm, we're using AI in a lot of different ways. And we're looking at AI on a lot of different, you know, things that we're doing now. What will that be in the future? And, you know, my position and your position and the position of our partners is, you know, not to eliminate jobs, but to be more productive with the people that we have and to be able to reward them more. Right? So I don't I'm hoping that the people much more powerful than us realize boy if you had control of everything but nobody has any money you have nothing right like you just nobody's going to buy it and I think if people are smart and they look at it like like we are on a microcosm of going but if we can use this technology we we can do more it's hard to even source good employees now right it's hard to source expertise so now we could do more we can reward more we can do a better job for clients. And and I think that's that's something I know a lot of people are afraid of AI. I think I'm going to for a little while probably beating the drum on, you know, it's okay to think about all things that can go wrong, but maybe we want to think about the things that can go right because there's a lot more room for productivity. Again, the United States, you've been way more places than than I have, but even, you know, places that are developed, I mean, Canada doesn't even look like us on the stuff that we have and the stuff that we do. Japan, you know, who's very developed. Um, their cities are very high-tech, but the, you know, their rural areas, you know, make ours look rich. Um, so there's a lot of space out there to do things. So, Matt, final thoughts from you today?
>> Yeah, I think, uh, we're still in a good position. The the AI is still the story behind the stock market. It hasn't filtered down fully into the economy yet. So, we haven't gotten the full economic gains of that and I think it's still going to take some time. But for now, things are on a okay footing uh pending a trade war, right? Like two weeks from now, we can talk again and we might be in a full-blown trade war or we might be hugging it out with China. I have no clue where this thing's going to go. And so, we just kind of got to pay attention. There's going to be, I'd say, a lot of noise. Anybody's tweet or interview in the administration can move the markets in the near term. But the long term it is all about earnings growth, profitability, all those things. I love it. And I'll tell you my final thought is we didn't talk about it and it doesn't necessarily affect things here but you know really great news out of the Middle East this week and the honestly that gives us a lot of for you know pardon the pun but currency with the rest of the world right now you know and and it does even put people like China on notice that the rest of the world is looking at the United States at least in this it's almost a throwback to that beacon on the hill right that um we are striving for peace we're doing some amazing things. So, uh, happy for all of our, you know, all the United States citizens that were affected by that and all the people in the Middle East. Matt, any ideas? I I don't have any, but are there any ideas on what we might talk about next time or we're just going to wait to see what happens in the next two weeks?
>> Yeah, I think uh, like I said, next two weeks, government shutdown, China, you know, trade talks. Um, those are the two big ones. Uh we also did have some other questions that we can can reference. Uh and you know we don't necessarily need to talk about right now but AI is is certainly we certainly can go deep on. We've covered you know a little bit of it today but we can go a little bit deeper as well of what it means in the economy and the markets. >> All right. Well thanks Matt. I tell everybody again like you'll see an email address at the bottom. Certainly feel free to send any ideas of things you want us to talk about there or talk to your adviser or any team member at Trillium. Um, you know, we meet uh the whole team meets every week. So, if we if we hear from somebody um that wants to hear something out there, we want to stay u timely and deliver, you know, information that our clients want. So, thanks, Matt.
>> Thanks. Good talk.
Keep listening.
What the Midterms Could Mean for Markets and AI
November 10, 2026 · 37 min
Episode notes →Market & economyWhat the Bond Market Is Telling Us About the Economy
September 29, 2026 · 14 min
Episode notes →Market & economyWhy the Fed Is Raising Rates When the Economy Is Still Strong
September 22, 2026 · 26 min
Episode notes →Start with a conversation.
Tell us what is on your mind. We will match you with an advisor near you, or meet by video.