The End of "Forward Guidance"
July 14, 2026 · Steve Laska, Matt Gomoll · 25 min

The End of "Forward Guidance"
July 14, 2026 · 25 min
Episode summary
In this July 2026 episode of Plain Talk, Steve Laska and Matt Gomoll discuss a shift Steve saw on a panel of central bankers in Europe: Fed Chair Kevin Warsh and his counterparts agreeing to move away from forward guidance. Matt explains that forward guidance is a central bank hinting at its future rate moves, and that the bond market got used to pricing those hints in immediately. He notes it has not always existed, quoting Alan Greenspan's line that if you understood what he said, he probably misspoke.
The hosts say Warsh described forward guidance as useful during the 2008 crisis, when rates were near zero and words were one of the few levers left, but not needed now. Matt stresses that Warsh is aiming to be less predictable, not less transparent: the Fed will still meet, explain its decisions and target 2% inflation. Steve adds that early-2026 expectations of two or three rate cuts turned within months into talk of possible hikes, which he sees as evidence that guidance often missed.
For investors, Matt expects bond prices to respond more to jobs and inflation reports, which can mean more volatility and higher yields demanded for uncertainty. Both hosts say this makes skilled active bond management more important, and Steve suggests the traditional 60/40 portfolio may be more useful for retirees again.
Key takeaways
- Matt explained that forward guidance is a central bank signaling future rate moves, which bond markets have tended to price in immediately.
- Steve said central bankers on the European panel he watched, including Kevin Warsh, agreed on moving away from forward guidance.
- Matt said Warsh saw forward guidance as a useful tool when rates were near zero during the 2008 crisis but not one that fits current conditions.
- Matt said the Fed under Warsh aims to be less predictable, not less transparent, and continues to emphasize price stability and the 2% inflation target.
- Matt expects bond prices to react more to jobs and inflation data, which could bring more volatility and higher yields to compensate for uncertainty.
- Both hosts said that less guidance makes skilled, active bond managers more valuable than simply tracking the aggregate bond index.
- Steve suggested a traditional 60/40 portfolio built around skilled bond management may again be a useful option for retirees.
Questions this episode answers
What is Fed forward guidance?
In this July 2026 episode, Matt Gomoll explained that forward guidance is the Federal Reserve or another central bank hinting at what it plans to do with rates, such as saying it holds steady now but expects a certain number of cuts. He said bond markets got in the habit of pricing that guidance in immediately rather than reading economic data for themselves.
Why is the Fed ending forward guidance?
Matt Gomoll said that Fed Chair Kevin Warsh viewed forward guidance as useful in the 2008 crisis, when rates were near zero, but not appropriate today. He said central bankers have expressed concern that guidance locks them into a path of expectations, and that dropping it restores their flexibility to respond to data. Steve Laska noted that rate expectations had swung from cuts to possible hikes within a few months in 2026.
How does the end of forward guidance affect bond investors?
Matt Gomoll said that without forward guidance, bond investors have to do more of their own research. He expects markets to react more to jobs, economic and inflation reports, which can mean more volatility. He also said investors may demand more yield for the added uncertainty, and that this makes skilled active bond managers more important than just tracking the aggregate bond index.
Plain Talk reflects the views of the speakers as of the recording date and is provided for informational purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security or a guarantee of future results. Market conditions change; talk with your advisor before acting on anything discussed.
Full transcriptRead the full conversation
Automatically transcribed from the episode audio; may contain minor errors. Select a timestamp to play from that point.
Welcome to Plain Talk with Trillium Wealth. I'm Steve Laska, managing partner here at Trillium Wealth. And as usual, along with my partner, who is also our chief investment officer, Matt Gomoll. And how are you doing today, Matt? Doing good. Yeah. All right. So the topic at hand is I was watching the Central Bankers talk in Europe, Warsh and the other ones about some new things going forward. And it was very, very compelling to me. And the big thing that to me, my big takeaway was the end of forward guidance. So why don't you start with telling our folks what that? What does forward guidance even mean? Yeah. So forward guidance is the Federal Reserve or any central bank hinting at what they're going to do, right?
Like this meeting, we held right steady, but we see X number of rate cuts. Or we see these conditions that are going to lead us to rate cuts or rate hikes. And interestingly, this is not been around forever. We didn't really have forward guidance in the past. Alan Greenspan once said, if you understood what I said, I probably misspoke. So there was a time not that long ago, where the Fed intentionally didn't forecast what they were about to do. I allowed them to be more nimble with responding to economic conditions at each meeting. Then we got to a period of where we do, the Fed did get in a trend of giving forward guidance. And it's essentially like setting out a path and broadcasting to the investment market, where we think things are going, not necessarily bound to them until we make a decision down the road.
But it's that forecast that says, yeah, we see it going this way. And bonds just start pricing immediately. So instead of waiting till the event, or instead of bonds reading the economic conditions and reports that come out and pricing things as they see fit, the bond market got in the habit of saying, all right, what did the Fed say? We're going to just take them at their word and forecast that that's going to occur. So actually, I've talked about this in the past in our podcast, where I talked about how the Fed traded and rumor a little bit. And it was interesting because I didn't necessarily know when it happened. I love your quote from Greenspan. But in doing some research and watching this, one, Kevin Warsh was around during the crisis in 2008 as a Fed Reserve governor. And he basically said like, hey, we're unapologetic about the fact that we were given forward guidance back then.
Like we really did feel like we had to temper the market times, we had the stoke, the flames a little bit at times. And he said that it was a very useful tool during a financial crisis, but said, I don't think we need to do that right now. Like we're not in a financial crisis and we need to let the markets decide where the economy is going rather than us telling them. And it is, you know, for people that don't know, there's an old adage, you know, economists are just like weathermen, they're right 50% of the time. And so some of the time, you know, people sitting on the Fed and looking at their teams of think tanks, economists, it's like, you also can't get any of them to agree. So whoever you have in there, if they're stressing something that's going in one direction, they may have been manipulating the market the wrong way. And to me, Warsh, like I said, he was unapologetic about being down in the past, but he also seemed to say, we probably shouldn't have been doing this for a while now.
Like it's been the wrong move for a while. Yeah, and so like it certainly is a lever to pull, right? You can move right, you can change rates, or you could just say words that hint that you might change rates. Either one is moving the market. And so back then, away to nine, they took rates near zero. And so there was no more nothing else to pull on the lower and rate side. So then you could use guidance, right? So that's kind of where it makes sense. Like it's a tool, it should be used when appropriate and they used it back then. And basically, Warsh was saying, yeah, it doesn't fit right now. We don't want it. What I thought Matt, that was really cool and I was really intrigued by it. So what I was watching was on CNBC, watching a panel of the powerful central bankers in Europe and Warsh up there, having a discussion.
I loved the mutual respect that was shown. And what really excited me for kind of the world economy is, these are the most powerful voices in the world on interest rates and things that move markets. And they're in lockstep on this. Like every single one of them said, no more forward guidance. So it literally wasn't just the USA in it. And it was funny because every time the person running the panel tried to even get in there, they all laughed at like no more forward guidance, right? No more forward guidance. I think one of them, maybe the guy, the guy from Great Britain, like joke, like, okay, I'm gonna give you a little bit here. And it was just kind of revisionist history. But the central banks working in concert with each other is a really good thing. And it's a thing where we've talked in recent podcasts about the power that the US economy has and all those. We already have that power.
I actually love that Kevin Warsh is not continuing the flex. I think it's better for us all if all of those people are saying, we will conduct ourselves the same way. Now that's not to say that they're gonna raise rates at the same time. They absolutely talked about like we have different economies and different things that work for us at different times. So it wasn't like we're all gonna raise rates at the same time. We're all gonna cut rates at the same time. They're, you know, they're working on their economies, but all of them going forward with this because we know that it's a world market now and everything that's happening has a trickle down effect. So what does it mean by the way to our clients now? Like what does it mean? What does it mean for their portfolios? What does it mean for what inflation looks like when people are know when the big banks are no longer doing this? Yeah. So I think it's important to note that Warsh from the start, taking over, has been very clear that price stability matters, right?
So he's not saying, oh, inflation's fine. We're just gonna let it run. He's saying, no, we have a mandate on price stability and we want to hit it. Now, I'm not gonna tell you what we're gonna do. I'm gonna forecast what we're gonna do on rates to accomplish that. If that has many levers to pull rates being won, but he's trying to anchor inflation expectations so that they don't stay elevated, right? That's what we wanna avoid. And, you know, if inflation rates stay elevated, you kind of get forced into raising the interest rate to try to tamp down on that inflation and that whole cycle. So he's trying to keep things anchored, wants to be in the two, you know, hit that 2% mandate. And what this means without forward guidance, bond investors have to do more homework on their own, right? Instead of just waiting for the next Fed meeting and saying, oh, what did they say?
We're just gonna price, you know, we're gonna price in these rate cuts or these rate hikes based on what they said. It, and he said this specifically, he's like, no, you gotta do your own research and evaluate all the different sources of data that we might be getting in. And by the way, like the Fed might change some of their sources of data and how they collect it and, you know, make it more timely. That can introduce volatility, right? There might be more volatility in the bond market because there's less certainty, less forward guidance, less certainty about what things look like six months a year from now because the Fed's not telling you anymore. Now the bond market's more responsive to things like jobs, reports, you know, economic condition reports, inflation reports, all those things. So that's kind of where I see it going. Doesn't necessarily mean it's a bad thing.
It can be a healthy part of the economy. Just, you know, I frankly think active bond managers matter a lot, right? So rather than just being tied to the aggregate bond index and just riding it out, I think having smart active bond managers really makes sense going forward. Yeah, I've always been a proponent that managing bonds is often more difficult than managing equities. I mean, it's way more science-based and many years ago, I was the National Sales Manager at PIMCO, which is, you know, the goat of bonds, right? And had a lot of great managers, not just Bill Gross, like the guys there were very talented. And so I think that the good news for our investors is, I think it's great. I think it actually offers more upside opportunity for investors if their advisors have the skill sets that we do and do the due diligence that we do to go out and select the right managers.
Like it going back to what our job is, and I enjoy this part, as I know you do as well, is going out and finding the highest quality managers. And, you know, a lot of that, the whole world has kind of moved to this, they want to index everything, even in places where indexes aren't readily available. And bonds is one of those. So I'm actually excited for our investors that I think there'll be more, money more opportunities in the bond market for them and do well. I've been in this business a long time, and the old 60-40 portfolio was a really good portfolio for retirees because if you hired a skilled bond manager, that was legit. Like you were getting, you could build a really great financial plan around that, and people could live really well in retirement without taking on the risk and volatility of the stock market. So I think that's back. And I don't think that's gonna change anytime soon.
Like I said, I think they're pretty strident that this is the way forward. And if you just look at it, by the way, just look at the forward guidance, a forward guide, it's ironic that we're gonna do it and talk about it right now because it's, we have a live example this year. I mean, two months ago, three months ago, they were like, yep, or actually before the war, for sure, they were like, we're gonna raise rates, two or three, are we gonna lower rates two or three times this year? And within a three month period, it went to, you know, we might actually raise rates. So it was always nonsense. It was nonsense because the world is moving pretty fast and the guidance was like I said, it was like predicting the weather. Things are gonna change. Yeah, the Fed definitely, and all the central banks, kind of took back their flexibility because they've, and these chairman and governors have mentioned, hey, it feels like when we give guidance, we're stuck on this path of expectations.
And that's not good because like you said, we could come into 20, 26, feel like, and give guidance towards some rate cuts down the road and the bond market's gonna price that in. And then we get a period like the, you know, the Iran war kicking off and through March, inflation's going up, oil prices going up, and a response could be, oh my gosh, the Fed needs to do something about this. But another response, you know, allowing them to retain the flexibility is say, well, wait, let's just wait, let's let this play out because we don't think six to 12 months from now, this problem persists to the point that we need to take action raising rates, right? Like let it work through the system. Yeah, inflation's gonna be higher for a while. It's gonna extend past the war, but we don't need to take action. So allowing themselves that flexibility, you know, not doing something, not raising rates is a decision in itself, right?
And so they have the flexibility to stop being stuck with the guidance and say, we're just watching the data. And, you know, the other thing, as, as Warsh came into this position, a lot of talk about independence, the Fed's credibility, you know, some attacks on the Fed against Powell and Lisa Cook. It does seem like the Fed's independence, both with the Supreme Court ruling that you can't just fire a Fed governor out of nowhere. And then, Warsh's actions, he's trying to make sure the credibility of the Fed is stable. Certainly, the administration would love some rate cuts, and he knows he can't deliver him right now. And so he's doing a pretty good job of trying to talk credibility, rebuild that for the Fed while giving less guidance, being less predictable.
You know, probably may not be able to deliver a rate cut that the administration wants right now, but the credibility side that he's enhancing is really good. Yeah, you talked about volatility, and it's not just in the bond market, it'll happen in the stock market as well. And, you know, you and I are gonna do one, a podcast here upcoming soon on, you know, the need for professional advice and advisors. And this is for somebody that loves this business, like I do and loves to help, you know, clients like I do, like it, volatility presents really great opportunities. So I don't look at it as a negative, you know, like I don't look at why you use an advisor as, you know, you're protecting yourself from not doing well. I think that there's a side of me that looks and says, you know, understanding markets and understanding works provide more opportunity for you to do better, right?
And volatility is a key in that. Like over the last, man, it's been a while now, like 10 or 12 years, there hasn't really been a lot of directional volatility. So the truth is there haven't been as many buying opportunities. And everybody's kind of sucked into this. I hope I get the next great IPO. I hope I, you know, I'm gonna make money if I buy Nvidia at the right time. And the reality is in normal markets where you have directional volatility and you can select good money managers and you understand how money and cash flow works, opportunities are abundant because investors, what we see, right, are investors in general, it's not like you're at a certain age, you know, like, you know, Matt, you just had a birthday or 43 and somebody goes, like, here's $6 million, man, here you go. This is it, you're not gonna get any more ever again. This is $6 million start to manage it, right? At that case, you'd probably be like, okay, I'm an index, maybe that works, maybe it doesn't.
We tend to accumulate money over time. And if I look at our own client base, our clients are really strong investors. Like they have X number of dollars when they come to us. And every year they're like, I have a little bit more money or I have a lot more money because I did this transaction and that transaction. And if you understand directional volatility, you can take advantage of those things and people can do very, very well. Many more opportunities. I've seen stuff where, and a lot of stuff came over the last 12 years. When you retire, your retirement is based on a lot of luck on what the market did. Cause you're moving this big chunk of money, right? And if you happen to do it at the wrong time, you might have a different experience than somebody else. These kinds of things, I believe, bring a lot more efficacy to markets and investing when they go back to what they did in the old days, which is to say, capitalism works, market movements works, let the world decide what it is as opposed to us telling you what's about to happen.
And again, we can point to so many times where it was a false narrative and not intentional. I'm not accusing central bankers of doing anything intentional. They were dealing with the information they had in front of them at the time. And I can go back to 2008 and show you a lot of times who are right and show you a lot of times where they were just like, man, we're wrong, including this last four months. Yeah. Yeah. And I think it's important, there's going to be criticism over, anytime you have something you take it away, it's different. People react and say, oh, why are we leaving this system? And it's, Warsh is not trying to make the Fed less transparent, just less predictive. Still going to have their meetings and still have output from the meetings and still explain why they view the economy, what data sources they're using, what they're seeing in the economy and why they're making the decisions they're making.
That's transparency. The added part of I'm going to tell you what we're going to do next is that's additional. That's not necessary and that is what he's saying we're going to get rid of. Well, I think we're Chairman Warsh, I love what you just said. And I think one of the things he pointed out as well is there's not going to be any of these press conferences, like there have been for the last 20 years where the Fed chairman just randomly talks about what's coming up at the meeting and what might happen. Like he literally said, I'm going to talk less. Like he's very clear on it. You're not going to see a lot of press conferences and that's what those press conferences were with Powell and people before. It was like, I'm going to get on here because I'm trying to temper the market or I'm trying to kick it in gear. He's literally saying, you will only hear from me when we have a meeting and you know when the meetings are. And unless there's an emergency, he's not suggesting there's not an emergency. Like something can happen where we call an emergency meeting but it won't be like it has been for the last 20 years where it literally is the Fed chairman might talk at any given time and give you a hint.
They're used to give hints of what might happen at the next meeting. And he's saying no more of that. I think it's great. I really do. I'm intrigued. Those all need to be understood as deliberate communication strategies. Anytime a Fed governor's out there talking, they're not just off the cuff saying whatever they want. These are deliberate communication strategies to get a message out to the market and it's a lever, right? Again, Fed can go talk and pull a lever or the Fed can have a meeting decide on rates, tell you why they did that and that can be their lever, right? So this is just a different communication strategy. Yeah, I would also say like we shouldn't be naive. Like it doesn't mean other people aren't gonna be predictive. You know, it doesn't mean other people like you're gonna have economists from all the big wire houses come out and tell you because I lived in that time, right?
There's gonna be plenty of people trying to tell you what's about to happen. I think the difference on some of the people that are gonna tell you what's about to happen is they're actually making moves. Like the Fed has monetary policy and that's it, right? They're not investing dollars. So the cool thing is now you'll see some of the predictive nature of you'll follow the money. Like where is this money being invested right now? So I think you'll still get great data from really smart people, but it's smart people that they are legitimately moving the market through their actions and their movement of money. Like, you know, there was a time where you would look and say, well, I know where the account, I know where the economy might be going because I'm watching the moves that Caterpillar's making. Like they're making these capital investments right now because construction's coming and they're doing all these things and it's a better place to look by the way.
Like it's a very, it's a big company with a lot of shareholders and they're moving money in certain directions. Like I spent a lot of time around a man named Sheridan Titman who wrote the first paper on Momentum and he said there was a time when, and this goes back a ways when I spent time with him. He's like, the greatest inside information that everybody has access to is when a CEO is buying their own stock back. And I said, what do you mean? And he said like, not all CEOs, but really good CEOs. He's like, people think they're doing that to inflate stock price. He goes, the really great CEOs of the world, the Jack Welch is back in the day. If they're buying their stock back, it's because that they think their stock is a good investment. They're not just diluting it. They're not just doing some of those things. And what's the balance of what they're buying back and what they're reinvesting in the business?
He's like, if they're buying all of it back, well, maybe they are making a move to inflate their stock as opposed to investing back in their own company. But he's like, there were very simple levers that you can look at on how the world really moves. And those are the things that really move it. That's not rumor. If a big company is investing their capital back into themselves or their buying stock back or their buying part of their stock back, these are all things that are very quantitative on where those things will likely move. Nothing's ever a guarantee. Yep. And the markets having more of a say, they've already exercised their power. And we've seen the bond market exercise, its power in the past when certain policy decisions are made and yield spiked because investors get nervous and they don't like that policy.
And maybe the administration moves off of it because they said, ooh, I see what went on there. Bond investors can demand more yield due to uncertainty. That's a feature that's gonna present itself. If you know exactly what the Fed's gonna do because they gave you forward guidance and they keep hitting their forward guidance like clockwork, you demand, there's less uncertainty and you demand less spread for that risk of uncertainty. If there's more uncertainty, bond investors are gonna say, we're not sure. We have a view, we have an opinion based on all these things, but we need a little more compensation to invest in that. And that's okay, right? And bond managers will be able to take advantage of those things and express their opinion. So Matt, I think that just leads into next time. I think we really should on our next podcast, advocate just based on the information we gave, it's a really strong compelling story for why should people use professional advice.
And I think we're gonna do that one next, right? Where we come out and say, I mean, there's always been a reason to do it, but this is kind of a catalyst on, again, having more opportunity by understanding what's happening in the markets and then tying it back to everything, be it your financial plan, your tax situation. So this one kind of led us into the next one, I believe, and we'll put that one out next, but we'll keep an eye out for the Fed and what they're doing, any closing thoughts? No, I think it's, the Fed's in a good place. There was plenty of worry leading up to this transition about what things would look like. I mean, Chairman Powell was under investigation, and Lisa Cook has a whole thing going on. So it was under attack, it feels more stable now. You're right, we're two months into this, it feels like things are gonna be just fine.
Great, well, thanks Matt. And thanks to everybody for joining us again. As usual, we'd love to hear from you if you have a topic that you wanna hear about, obviously click and subscribe, and you should see us in more places coming up. We're trying to get our message out a little bit more, so there'll be many different places you can listen to us or watch us on our podcast. And again, we're here to serve you. So until next time, on behalf of Matt and myself, we'll see you in a week or two.
Keep listening.
What the Midterms Could Mean for Markets and AI
November 10, 2026 · 37 min
Episode notes →Market & economyWhat the Bond Market Is Telling Us About the Economy
September 29, 2026 · 14 min
Episode notes →Market & economyWhy the Fed Is Raising Rates When the Economy Is Still Strong
September 22, 2026 · 26 min
Episode notes →Start with a conversation.
Tell us what is on your mind. We will match you with an advisor near you, or meet by video.