Trillium Wealth
Plain Talk · Investing

Why the Biggest IPOs May Not Offer the Biggest Returns

August 4, 2026 · Steve Laska, Matt Gomoll · 27 min

Plain Talk podcast
Plain Talk

Why the Biggest IPOs May Not Offer the Biggest Returns

August 4, 2026 · 27 min

Episode summary

In this August 2026 episode of Plain Talk, Steve Laska and Matt Gomoll argue that the most talked-about IPOs, including SpaceX and the expected listings of Anthropic and OpenAI, may not offer the outsized returns investors hope for, because much of the growth has already happened while the companies were private. Matt notes that Amazon has returned something like 250,000% since it listed, and that investors could share in that in the public market. Companies now stay private far longer and go public at valuations above a trillion dollars.

Matt explains how SpaceX used a low float: only about four to four and a half percent of shares were available to trade at first, roughly 70 billion dollars of stock at the 135 dollar issue price. With more buyers than shares, the price popped and then came back down. He expects lockup expirations and inclusion in indexes such as the Nasdaq, Russell and CRSP to balance supply and demand, and thinks Anthropic or OpenAI may copy the approach. The hosts also discuss governance: Matt says there was a large "Elon premium" in SpaceX and doubts other founders will get the same leeway on voting control.

Matt suggests investors who like IPOs look at venture capital and private equity, where returns build earlier, and cautions against chasing a 20% day-one pop that can just as easily be a 20% drop.

Key takeaways

  • Matt said that companies now stay private much longer, so more of their growth goes to private investors before the IPO.
  • Matt explained that float is the share of a company's stock actually available to trade, and that SpaceX listed with only about four to four and a half percent of its shares.
  • Matt said a low float plus strong demand pushed the SpaceX price up early, and that lockup expirations and index inclusion would bring more shares and new buyers over time.
  • Matt described Anthropic and OpenAI as purer AI businesses than SpaceX, which carries more risk if enterprises decide the cost is not worth the value.
  • Matt said there was a large Elon premium built into SpaceX and doubted that other AI founders would get the same leeway on governance and voting control.
  • Matt suggested that investors drawn to IPOs consider venture capital and private equity, where returns tend to build before a company goes public.
  • Matt cautioned against chasing a day-one IPO pop, noting that a 20% gain can just as easily be a 20% loss.

Questions this episode answers

Is it a good idea to buy stock at an IPO?

In this August 2026 episode, Matt Gomoll said today's largest IPOs come after companies have stayed private for years, so much of the growth has already gone to private investors. He said that does not rule out good returns, but chasing a 20% day-one gain carries risk, since the stock can also fall 20%. He suggested waiting a couple of months for volatility to settle rather than adding an overweight position at the IPO.

What does float mean in an IPO?

Matt Gomoll explained that float is the portion of a company's shares actually issued for public trading. In the SpaceX IPO, he said, only about four to four and a half percent of shares traded at first, roughly 70 billion dollars of stock at the 135 dollar issue price, while insiders and private investors were locked up. With more buyers than available shares, the price rose early and then came back down.

How do index funds add a new IPO like SpaceX?

Matt Gomoll said indexes generally weight a new company by the stock actually available, not its headline valuation. He said the Nasdaq applied about a three-times multiplier to SpaceX's float, sizing it well above the float but far below its full market value. He noted some institutions bought at the IPO expecting to sell to index funds on inclusion day.

How can investors get exposure to companies before they go public?

Matt Gomoll said that most returns now accrue before the IPO to venture capital funds, private equity funds and some mutual funds, which he said can hold up to 15% of their assets in private companies. He said that if you like the idea of investing in IPOs, you would like venture capital, because the IPO is the endpoint of that cycle. Steve Laska added that venture investing is more speculative by nature and benefits from professional diversification.

Plain Talk reflects the views of the speakers as of the recording date and is provided for informational purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security or a guarantee of future results. Market conditions change; talk with your advisor before acting on anything discussed.

Full transcriptRead the full conversation

Automatically transcribed from the episode audio; may contain minor errors. Select a timestamp to play from that point.

Welcome to Plain Talk with Trillium Wealth. My name is Steve Laska. I'm the Managing Partner here at Trillium Wealth. And I'm here with my partner and our Chief Investment Officer, Matt Gomoll. This one I think might be a little bit shorter on what we're doing because we're going to be like very direct topical on this one, Matt. Let's talk a little bit about IPOs. Like everybody just had the SpaceX IPO and there's a lot of euphoria I talked about how it just went so far up, so far down, so far back in the middle. But there's a lot of excitement out of a lot of them coming up. This is, SpaceX was one, but I think there are some really big names that are about to launch and you have some insights on like just, there's different ways to launch an IPO, right? Like is it all available or is there some tiny part available? And what does that mean?

And if we take the, did Elon Musk with his kind of background and power set a new paradigm for others to follow or was he an outlier? I'd love to hear your opinions on what it'll look like with things like Anthropic and others. Yeah, Elon's always an outlier. He is one of one, is a unique figure in the technology, manufacturing, investing space. He's just very unique. However, I think some of the things he did might be replicated by the next major. I mean, the idea of a trillion dollar IPO is crazy. It is not something that markets have seen before. So it's very unique and kind of, it's a sign of the times of these types of companies have been able to stay private this long and now IPO at over a trillion dollars.

So, Elon's unique, however, comma, I do think Anthropic and OpenAI are going to follow suit and do some similar things to what he did. I think they're going to have some pricing control on setting. I think they can go out with a low float. I think they can get inclusion in the indexes pretty quickly just the way he did. So those are all major differences from what we would have seen on a normal IPO that comes in at a couple billion dollars. Although we talked about it before Matt, like give our clients a little bit of insight on it. I think they understand indexes like being in the S&P or NASDAQ or the Russell, but float. Talk to a little bit about what it means and why the lower float allows probably more stability in the IPO price where it's going to go up and come back down.

But once we've seen in the past, there hasn't been uncommon for much lower share price than Musk. But it launches at 20 and by the end of the month, it's at 12. What does float mean to our investors and why does that kind of cause a little bit of price stability and leave power in the hands of the current major shareholders? Yeah. So float is the idea of how much of a stock has 100% shares, but only some amount of those shares are being publicly issued for trading. In the case of SpaceX, Elon owns the majority of the company. He wasn't trading anything and his stuff was locked up. A lot of the other insiders, whether they're employees who did very well, having been working there for years, they had stock that's locked up. Also private investors, right?

Venture capital funds and maybe some private equity funds who got in towards the end. All those folks have lockups that SpaceX was a little complicated, but there's a timeline to be able to free up those shares and sell. So there was a chunk of shares. It was only, I think it was like four, four and a half percent of the total shares that were available for trading that first week. So that was the float. Float was like $70 billion or so at the issue price of $135. And so while the headline is, this is a $1.7 trillion company or whatever at IPO, it's really a $70 billion chunk of stock that's available out there, right? That's all it is. And so that, when you don't issue that much stock for sale and there's plenty of demand, well, there's more buyers than there is stock available.

Price went up. Now over the period of time, last couple of weeks, it's traded a little more normally, right? Like pop happened over the first few days, it came back down. It still hasn't breached its issue price at $135. But we're entering a period where more and more stocks are going to be available because more floats available. The lockups from those private investors, the insiders are coming available to the market right as some of the indexes are set to include it, right? So as the NASDAQ set to include it and the Russell and the CRSP index are set to include it in their index, well, that's going to drive some demand as new float becomes available. So there's a little bit of that back and forth of supply and demand and creating a little bit of stability that we might not have seen otherwise.

And I do think that's a technique that Anthropic or OpenAI might try to replicate. Do you foresee like when we talk about the indexes, if you look at certain cap weighted indexes and all that they want to be included in, if there's not enough for them to purchase within their index? Yeah, so like some of the indexes are going to look at it and say, oh, there's there's 70 billion dollars of stock available. That makes it this weight in our index. And so we're going to wait it appropriately. The NASDAQ came out and I think they did like a three time multiplier on float. So they were, they were considering it a $200 and something billion stock. And now, you know, wherever it trades upon inclusion day. So they're sizing it a little bigger than the actual float, but not nearly it's not weighted in the index as a two trillion stock dollar company or whatever it is today. So yeah, there's a little bit of nuance of how they're doing it.

And, you know, frankly, they want to find shares. And I think some of the buyers of, you know, SpaceX IPO were what we would call like warehouse ing stock like might be hedge funds, might be institutions who say, hey, I'm just going to buy it at this price and hold it for a few weeks because I know NASDAQ's going to come in and they're just going to buy it from me. So that's kind of going on, right? So some of those institutional players or hedge funds might offload their stock because it wasn't a long term investment for them. It was really just a trade get from here to I know there's going to be these buyers coming. So let's talk a little bit like, well, they're wonderful opportunities. Don't get me wrong. Like, you know, Anthropics going to be a strong stock. Like it's not, I don't see it as very speculative at this point. That's the upside to trillion dollar IPOs, right? It's like, you know, the company like, you know, Apple at one time was a fledgling company out to a wealthy trillion dollar company, Microsoft, all these companies.

In this case, these companies have been around for a good amount of time too. So I see different ways that people can get hurt or I see different ways that people can benefit that don't think everybody's thinking about. One, if you get into the fury of the IPO, you can get hurt. We can just look at SpaceX. I mean, there were people buying it at two 30 or whatever that number was, right? There's a reason why it hit that price. There were people buying it at that. And so some people took it on the chin inside of a week, but there's another place like, look, a lot of times when clients don't understand private equity, this is a way to benefit from IPOs. We look at, there's some big names out there, but, you know, we use companies like StepStone and you've looked at other private equity investments like some of these people in those investments are benefiting from IPOs more often than they think. Like a private equity firm is going in there and being an early investor or eventual capital funds being in there and being an early investor.

We know that StepStone has had somewhere, you know, they're buying it on the secondary market before it, you know, goes public and the upside to those things are really, really great. Talk about for you in your job as a chief investment officer, the different ways that you see people can benefit from an IPO like that versus just getting into the fury of it. Yeah. So, you know, the majority of these returns are accruing to those private investors prior to IPO, right? If we think about a company like Amazon, it has something like 250,000% return since it's listing. Insane, right? Like that, but picture, all of that accrued in the public market. So, as a regular investor, you could have gotten that right, participated. You've certainly participated along the way as it's been in an index and been a large part of the S&P of the Nasdaq.

These companies listing at a trillion, a lot of those returns already occurred. And they accrue to the private investors who are venture capital funds, private equity funds, other, you know, interestingly, mutual funds can actually hold some, like, up to 15% of their fund in private companies. And we know some mutual funds, we've used them that have done that before. So, you know, chasing some of these and saying, oh, I'm going to get, you know, Amazon like returns over the next 10 years, that's hard to see at these, you know, number one valuations and just market caps that they're entering the company doesn't mean you can't have good returns in them. Just there's a, there's a market difference between companies that used to go public much, much earlier in their lifecycle to today, companies staying private much, much longer, which gets into, yeah, like a way to access that is through either venture capital funds, private equity funds, some sort of mutual funds that we know are participating in the private markets.

And right, so trying to say, hey, these are long-term investments and I want to participate in that return and that value creation that's occurring in private markets versus this is my first chance in the IPO, let me jump on the train and say, you can go up for sure. Just not that like 10-bagger return that you could have had in the past, right? I don't see Anthropic 10-exing in the public markets anytime soon. And that's the best point. I think where people get excited about something as they do, they look at something like you give a great example on Amazon, but I will tell you, most of the people that benefit it from the 250,000 percent return, they work there, right? They weren't even early investors, they were early workers there. Jeff Bezos made that money and there were probably a handful of private, private, not a private equity fund, like a guy, right? Who's going, I'm going to back you.

And that's what I always want to caution our clients on. These IPOs are great. And if you've heard of the company, if it's omnipresent throughout the world right now, your upside is definitely tempered. We have lots of things. Like I said, we have investments that you're putting our wealthier clients in today that are going to benefit from IPOs on defense contractors and stuff that they're a 25-person company right now. And there's some real heft of what can happen when those things go right. So I think they're great investments. That's what I want our investors to know. If Anthropic goes out at a trillion-dollar valuation, it's a pretty good haul for you to double your money in that stock. Typically, the stock market will double in six years or so. So that's what I want our clients to know. These are very exciting opportunities.

Don't think that if you got in SpaceX, that your money's even if you got in at the IPO, that your money's going to double in the next year. It would be hard. Because that is a, I think what folks don't realize as well is these IPOs have been heavily, heavily followed by analysts. There's no surprise on SpaceX or Anthropic. There's a bunch of really smart investment people that are looking at the numbers on those things every day. And they already have that trillion-dollar valuation for a very, very good reason. I don't know how many times historically a company's gone from a trillion to two trillion. Well, there haven't been that many trillion-dollar companies. So let me go back in time. There weren't a lot of times when companies go back 25 years ago when, like, I might be wrong on the exact dates here, but probably in 25 years ago, GE was the most valuable company in the world. Their Exxon was the most valuable company in the world. And they were bumping up, not quite a trillion, maybe in the high hundreds of millions. So we look historically, it would be a fun exercise for you and I to do on the investment committee to go.

Now, times that a company that was already established go from 400 billion in valuation back in the day to 800 in a couple of years, probably not. Then again, things have changed. What is your outlook on what it means for a client versus any other investment, by the way? Like, once you get past the euphoria of the IPO of SpaceX, when we go to the fall, once we get past the euphoria of Anthropic, of OpenAI, how do you in your job see it as the efficacy of the investment itself? Yeah, so this gets down to a lot of the US market is wrapped up in the AI trade right now. There's a lot of companies that are tied to it. Anthropic and OpenAI are uniquely that like, they are the frontier model. Their business model is delivering that AI model and those agents and stuff like that. Whereas a lot of the other players might be cloud providers, data center providers, software providers like Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Apple taking a different take on it. They're all participating, but it's slightly different. These are pure plays. Even SpaceX has a AI component with their XAI, but they have a lot of other stuff going on with data centers and rockets and satellites. They're a diversified company, especially if they got cursor they bought and they might roll up Tesla. That might happen. That's a very diversified play with a bunch of different business lines, whereas OpenAI and Anthropic are just pure. We need to generate revenue from users using our product.

That gets to, it's the pureest form of an AI investment. It gets to like, is this stuff going to have economic impact and our company is going to see value and keep paying for it. Right now they're like, Anthropics revenue is insane growth. They are growing insanely like no company before. But at the point where enterprises say, I'm spending too much on this, I'm not getting a value, or I don't like your closed model. I want to open model that I control in-house with my own data. Picture we went from a rack of servers to house your data probably 20 years ago, and then we migrated to the cloud. Now we're migrating to this. We're going to use your model with our data. Might come back to companies wanting to control their own data and just use an open source model on premises. That's kind of where I see I'm not sure it will be good for them to be public.

That's good. But there's certainly risk involved. If their business case proves out and they're valuable and they're adding value to their customers, those companies are going to pay a lot of money for that service. If not, if they're worried about privacy and data retention and all these things, then Anthropic and OpenAI, I have a business risk to them. Historically, when you look at companies, and those are great, I love the juxtaposition, actually, because I can tie it back to the past, a lot of companies when they're doing an IPO, or they're early in the euphoria, they're not profitable yet. They're valuation is based on what they think it's going to be, and it might be based on top line revenue. Amazon was a great example of that. Bezos spoke at the Washington Economic Forum seven or eight years ago and said, we were always profitable at the end point, but we weren't profitable as a company. That's what he was judging it out. On that end point, what I bought this for and what I sold it for, I'm profitable. Now, the shipping and everything else you have to figure out, and then, of course, the diversification of a company makes a big difference. Amazon, they're not really making as much money from shipping stuff and stuff you buy. They're making government contracts on data storage and things like that. You watch Meta saying, we have to diversify in order to maintain this. Somebody's coming out and trying to already match that. Other ones are coming out and diversifying.

If I go back in time to two companies I just mentioned, GE was a very diversified company. Jack Welch said, we have to be top three or I sell it, but they were top three in refrigerators, and they were top three in missiles. It's like, they basically touched everything. Exxon, if you overlaid it on the S&P and during their heyday, they look the same as an S&P 500 fund because their stuff was so, like their actual product was in so many things. Again, oil was used, it still is in so many things versus just cars and planes and boats. That is a cautionary tale a little bit on Anthropic and OpenAI. What does that business look like? How profitable are they today and where do they have to get to do it? If you're in one business line, the upside is, Anthropic actually could go from a trillion to 10 trillion. We don't even know what AI is going to look like from a valuation standpoint. They can also have the opposite happen. They will soon be held to a different standard. That's what we didn't talk about in the IPO. The one thing that Musk had that was very unique and I don't know if the other guys are going to get away with is, you're going to buy myself and your share is going to have a diluted vote to it.

I'm not even going to let you. I'm not giving you, you buy a full share, you don't get a full vote. I've locked that up. I don't know that they'll get away with that. When all of a sudden those private equity investors prices start to level out because they level out a lot of times in public markets versus private markets and you do have pension funds and you do have folks that are sitting there going, we actually want to vote our shares. You're held to a different standard on profitability. It's one reason why I think companies have stayed private longer is the ability to have the power to go. We want to go down this path and take this risk because we see the upside of it. No matter what institutional investors say, they don't think like that. If you're at the California pension fund, if you're at CalPERS, you're looking for an outcome versus this outsized growth. What do you think of the difference? Do you think that's going to be a difference in Anthropic and OpenAI versus Musk? All of a sudden they have some people at the table with shares that want to tighten things up a little bit and don't want it to be the wild wild west.

Yeah, I think it's fair to say there was a large Elon premium built into the SpaceX price. Credit, he's already built Tesla and investors have stuck around for a long, long time and been rewarded in that company. As SpaceX came public, people looked at it and said, hey, there might be hundreds of billions of dollars of Elon premium because I've seen him do this once before. I'm willing to give him that. I'm willing to seed some control over the governance, right? Because he's totally in control of it. You could sell a bunch of shares and still maintain control with his super voting shares. I don't think, to your point, Sam Altman and Dario at Anthropic have that same leeway. They haven't built public companies that investors benefited from. I don't think they've done a lot of good for their public perception. I've scared a lot of people about doomsday scenarios with AI, taking all your jobs, all these things.

So it's not their public perception isn't great. I don't know that public investors will love handing over a lot of authority to them, giving them a big premium and not being compensated for. So that's certainly a risk that they have. Yeah, I think the most premium, like you alluded to there, it's earned. It wasn't just Tesla. He's done lots of things where he's actually been a decision maker that's moved in certain directions. There will be, in my history suggests that there will be some people coming to the table, say it to OpenAI and Anthropic. You need a professional CEO. And ironically, there's a different pathway for this. Steve Ballmer, the owner of the LA Clippers, has all that Microsoft stock. He was there early and left. And Bill Gates hired him back because actually Bill Gates said, I'm going to be the chairman. I need somebody that operates this place differently. But that can take out certain creativity if you don't get the right people. So that will be interesting to follow, I believe.

Matt, any thoughts are kind of just to temper or excite people about what you think we'll be doing with respect to IPOs? Are we, I think we like to use things like private equity because we have professional people overlooking that and you have quietly a lot more exposure to that than you think. But what are the differences that you see and what are your things that you would say to somebody like, Hey, this is a good thing. And also I caution you on this. Yeah, I would say if you like the idea of investing in an IPO, you're going to love the idea of investing in venture capital. Because you're just getting ahead. You're getting ahead of that. You're going to get some of those private market returns or getting access to, you know, we see the headlines on SpaceX and Tropic in OpenAI. There are hundreds of companies in VC portfolios that could be that next thing. And so that's the, that's the play. If this kind of thing is interesting, the IPO is kind of the end endpoint of that cycle. I'd rather get in way earlier.

And we've begun doing that with with some of our clients. Then, you know, there is plenty of exposure to to the AI trade just in US stock markets, plenty of technology exposure, adding an overweight position to one of these, especially during the IPO, right, like, give it a couple months and let some of that volatility shake out. We don't necessarily need to chase a 20% day one return, right? Like that's, that's great and all. It also can go negative 20, right? So we're taking a lot of risk that I don't know is necessarily warranted. So it's, it, I would kind of reframe it as what are we trying to accomplish here? Big picture, we want growth, we want access to the, you know, high growth companies that aren't out there yet. Cool. That's where VC and private equity are acting today. Yeah, I honestly, I think that investors, and I think the way that we look at things is a little bit more skewed to what I said earlier and how an institutional investor looks itself, because our, our, our clients are looking for an outcome and they'd love to have the big return.

And I'd love to have the big return. And like you said, there are different ways to deliver that. And, and so if folks want to do it, it's like anything else. Like I think it's, it can be a great, great investment. It's a great investment for part of your retirement or future wealth. Typically people that, you know, historically have made money off of these things are again, people that, that work there and they work there real early and they see those things. So I'm excited, I'm excited about the different things that are out there and we'll, we'll certainly keep an eye out for, for, for our clients. And like I said, we'll have different ways to expose them to this over long term. And what you just mentioned when you're talking about things like venture funds, I mean, I don't know that we have a lot of clients in it, but like StepStone's Venture Fund, like some of the stuff has been great returns. And it's diversified by professional managers that understand like some of these things are going to be great. And some of these things that we think are going to be great. There's a reason why it's venture. There's a reason why, you know, it was more speculative to invest in Anthropic five years ago than it is today. So the rules haven't changed on investments. All right, Matt, thanks. As usual, great spending time with you and with our clients.

We always want people to give us feedback on things that you want to hear about, reach out to us and tell us, click and subscribe, share our information if you think it was valuable with others. And we'll look forward to seeing you next time.

Next step

Start with a conversation.

Tell us what is on your mind. We will match you with an advisor near you, or meet by video.

Start a conversation