Trillium Wealth
Plain Talk · Market & economy

Why the S&P 500 Stays Resilient During a Government Shutdown

October 30, 2025 · Steve Laska, Matt Gomoll · 25 min

Plain Talk podcast
Plain Talk

Why the S&P 500 Stays Resilient During a Government Shutdown

October 30, 2025 · 25 min

Episode summary

In this late October 2025 episode of Plain Talk, Steve Laska and Matt Gomoll revisit the government shutdown as it approaches a month. Matt points to SNAP benefits stopping on November 1st and a dispute over Affordable Care Act subsidies with no easy solution. Steve worries about knock-on effects on commerce, such as flight disruptions as air traffic controllers call in sick. Both expect the damage to show up over the next quarter or two, for example in travel company earnings, rather than long term.

The hosts then explain why the market has stayed strong. Matt cites a stat that 85% of S&P companies reporting so far had beaten expectations, while noting part of that is gamesmanship around guidance. He adds that clarity around tariffs has helped, and that the S&P was up a little over 18% for the year and about 39% off the April lows. Steve argues the breadth of earnings beats suggests strength beyond a handful of tech companies.

Matt notes many S&P 500 stocks are still 10% or more off their highs and makes the case for owning small caps, midcaps, international and value stocks, which he expects to benefit more as rates ease. The episode closes on the U.S.-China trade talks, including delayed tariffs, a one-year delay on rare earth export controls and renewed soybean purchases.

Key takeaways

  • As of late October 2025, Matt Gomoll said SNAP benefits were set to stop on November 1st, with the core disagreement centered on Affordable Care Act subsidies.
  • Both hosts expect shutdown effects, such as weaker travel and airline results, to show up over the next quarter or two rather than doing long-term damage.
  • Matt cited a stat that 85% of S&P companies reporting so far had beaten earnings expectations, while noting companies often guide low.
  • Steve Laska argued that the breadth of earnings beats points to strength well beyond a few large tech companies.
  • Matt said small caps, midcaps, international and value stocks have room to catch up and could benefit more than large tech companies as rates ease.
  • Matt described the U.S.-China talks as cooler heads prevailing, with planned November 1st tariffs delayed and rare earth export controls delayed a year.
  • Steve sees a possible silver lining in the U.S. building strategic reserves of critical minerals and pointed to a recent deal with Australia.

Questions this episode answers

Why is the stock market going up during the government shutdown?

In late October 2025, Matt Gomoll pointed to strong third-quarter earnings, citing a stat that 85% of S&P companies reporting so far had beaten expectations, along with more clarity on tariffs. Steve Laska argued the breadth of those beats shows strength beyond a few tech names. Both expected shutdown effects to show up in some companies' results over the next quarter or two without lasting long-term damage.

How does a government shutdown affect the economy?

Matt Gomoll said in October 2025 that SNAP benefits were set to stop on November 1st and that many government reports were simply not being produced. Steve Laska highlighted flight disruptions as air traffic controllers called in sick, which he sees as a direct hit to commerce and business travel. Both described the effects as trickling and likely to show up in the next quarter or two rather than long term.

What did the U.S. and China agree to on trade in October 2025?

Matt Gomoll described the talks as cooler heads finally prevailing after months of back and forth. He said tariffs planned for November 1st were delayed, China delayed its rare earth export controls by a year, and China agreed to restart soybean purchases, with discussion of fentanyl precursors and a TikTok deal as well. He noted these items were still being finalized when they recorded.

Should investors own small cap and international stocks?

Matt Gomoll said in October 2025 that while small and mid-sized companies have underperformed the AI tech sector, owning them is still useful for diversification away from concentration in U.S. tech. He argued that small caps, midcaps, international and value stocks have room to catch up and may benefit more from falling rates because their borrowing costs are higher. These are the hosts' general views, not recommendations for any individual.

Plain Talk reflects the views of the speakers as of the recording date and is provided for informational purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security or a guarantee of future results. Market conditions change; talk with your advisor before acting on anything discussed.

Full transcriptRead the full conversation

Automatically transcribed from the episode audio; may contain minor errors. Select a timestamp to play from that point.

Welcome to Trillium Plain Talk. I'm here as usual with my partner Matt Gomoll. Matt, today I didn't think we're going to have to talk about this, but it just keeps going, man. It just keeps going. We we we we we said, "Oh, you know, the government shutdown, it doesn't really have a long-term effect, but it's starting to get really long in the tooth." And there are some things that can really start to rear its head, you know, pretty quickly. >> Yeah, we are uh coming up on a month here. So, it is there there's been some things that the administration has been to kind of able to squeeze in. There were some payments to the troops that they were able to I don't know where find money for. Um there's a lot of stuff shut down. Uh there is, you know, the big one that's going to cause a lot of pain is ending November 1st, people are not going to be receiving SNAP benefits anymore. So I guess the program had money for October, but in November 1st, it's turned off, which is going to be devastating to those families who rely on that. And I think we're going to have a lot of a lot of complaints to Congress. Um so that is that's kind of like the week ahead. Um unfortunately the stuff doesn't move that quickly and if there's a solution it's going to feel like a band-aid. Um because the the underlying problem the the disagreement seems to be around these uh affordable care act subsidies that that's not an easy solution. So hopefully we get the government reopened with a continuing resolution, but I don't know how they solve the the disagreement they've got there.

>> So I think it's two levels. I I I definitely, you know, I I certainly feel for the families that won't get the SNAP benefits and hopefully, you know, there's another week or so we we can get to that. Um but that doesn't necessarily have the effect on some of the things the economy that I'm that I'm starting to feel could have an effect. And so when you start seeing flights shut down because air traffic controllers are calling in sick, >> now we're affecting commerce, number one. >> Um, number two, and you know, I travel a good amount for business. Um, I didn't have any trips scheduled. If I did, I'd probably be like, well, I'm not going to buy that ticket yet. I'm not going to buy that ticket yet. I mean, you're coming down here to go to a conference with me in about three weeks, right? I mean that that's something right there where it's like now now you're playing it for more time. Those are the kind of things that even like folks like yourself go, "Well, maybe I won't go to that one this year, right?" Uh because I don't want to get in stuck in the airport or possibly cancelled.

>> Now we have a storm ripping through, >> you know, another country or countries. Uh that's going to affect air travel as well all over the place and you don't have the right people doing the job right now. So some things, you know, it it's interesting. I saw your senator, who I hate, um, Ron Johnson, uh, but he did say something that I thought was really, really good. He kept trying to put he keeps trying to push a bill that makes shutting down the government illegal, >> right? He's like, okay. He's like, it always we always end up with the continuing resolution anyways. Um, so he's he's trying to, you know, say, why don't we just get rid of that? And I think he actually, you know, there's probably an agenda on that one, but I think he put another one forward that said, okay, why don't we put a bill for essentials, for the military, for air traffic control, for some of the different things that are out there now. But I believe we're getting to a point right now where these little trickling effects um can have some real damage. probably not long term, but as people are looking at their accounts and all, maybe next quarter and the quarter after.

>> Yeah, I agree. I don't think it's long term. It's one of those things that just you lose confidence in their ability to be serious about their job. And when Congress isn't doing their job and just keeping the lights on and the, you know, public places and keeping TSA paid and and getting the air traffic controllers to work and all those essential services, that's not good. You know, nobody's Congress was also already not very popular. This isn't helping their case. Um, so yeah, it's it's a problem that will I I agree work itself out over the next quarter or so. travel, you know, hotel companies, airlines, that's going to show up in the next quarter or two that they were they were diminished. They were hit in their earnings. Um, you know, another aspect of this is a lot of information comes out of the government from government reports that is just missing. And frankly, we're probably not going to go back and get it. You know, they're not going to go uh search for what October data was because they weren't at work in October. So, they'll just move on. Um, the interestingly, you probably saw in the news that the CPI has to put out a report. It's because there's a bunch of things tied to it.

There are co uh cost of living adjustments for social security that has to like they need a number to go off of. And so, the Bureau of Labor Statistics has to produce something. So, that's why out of everything in October, they gave you like one number uh on inflation data. also the the Treasury inflation uh protected securities, the TIPS market, they have to be they have to have that data, right? So, they that kind of got out there. Uh the good news is it was fine. You know, it's it's not two um so we're nowhere near two yet, but we are certainly off the highs we had for a few years there. It's heading in the right direction. It seems to be slowing down. uh rate of change still higher than we'd like, but um that kind of leads into this Fed decision. They got a meeting um I think this week uh uh coming up soon and they will >> Yeah, they're supposedly going to announce another quarter point rate cut. And the the CPI data just kind of reinforces that. It's like, yeah, inflation's not a scary number anymore. Jobs are more concerning. you should cut rates to, you know, ease ease conditions uh in the business world so that jobs aren't overly hurt. So, that's kind of a positive outlook. I guess >> it's a very active, you know, Treasury Secretary, you know, Scott Bessent. I watched him on TV the other day >> and I kind of listen, I liked it. They got to defend their positions sometimes and and and I've I've talked about on this before about how the Fed at times trades and well as does the government in um in rumor they kind of put stuff out there purposely to do stuff but really saw Bessent face somebody down when they were like well beef is up this much and this is up this much and he was like okay well you can cherrypick whatever you want. He's like but inflation even with those numbers is more under control right now. And he and I like the way he's kind of defending the position because so many things are moved on rumor that you got to get both sides of it. Now right now um it it's not even worth turning on because I can tell everybody whatever channel you turn on, one side's blaming the other side and boy they have great arguments. They they both do, >> right? U if if you're on their side, right? And we're somewhere in the middle. But it's a great segue actually. So, one of the things we wanted to talk about today and you just kind of alluded to a little bit how um earnings and how they may be affected the next quarter or the quarter after, but this time earnings were really good news.

>> Yeah. So, we are in the heart of earning season. So, it starts midocctober. So, generally like two weeks after a quarter ends, a new one starts, they you know, companies start coming out with their quarterly earnings. And, uh it's been pretty I heard a stat today um that was 85% of S&P companies reporting so far have beat expectations. Part of that is gamesmanship, right? Companies know to kind of guide a little bit lower, get their analysts to think it's going to be a little bit lower and then they beat by a couple cents, right? It's a game, but it's one that everybody enjoys. Like it when everybody beats it's great. It's just a sign that the market is strong. These companies are legitimately strong. It's not just that the stock market is, it's that their underlying fundamentals of their earnings are doing pretty good. Um, we've gotten a lot of clarity around tariffs, right? That was the big story earlier this year. Big concern. Nobody knew where it was going to go. We've gotten a lot of clarity. Companies have.

And so now we're kind of in a post tariff, you know, confusion era where we can move forward past that. they are what they are. Um and companies can plan around that and have pretty good earnings. And so a couple stats I had pulled um just for relation just since uh kind of earning season starts. I think the S&P total return is up a little over 3%. That's that's good for a month, you know, uh a couple weeks. The other one I wanted to look at was total return this year on the S&Ps about 18 a little over 18% um since the start of the year since the bottom of the market. So it was about April 8th or so um 39% up off that level. Right? So we've had a just a massive rally coming off of a big you know a big draw down uh from February into the tariff announcement.

and we've got it all back and then some. >> So I it's really interesting what you said about the number of companies in the earnings because again we're seeing the market continue to hit highs and you know Cherry had a client in here today. Smart guy, good client and still is like but the bubble's coming, right? And he and he's kind of refused to be in it for a while now and he's like I I know I've missed it. And you know, we're always telling people, heck, we've had we had people in the market that was at 4,400 predicting the bubble and here we're, you know, at almost 7,000, you know, fast forward just a couple years. What I think I want investors and clients to know right now though is what you said there. 85% of companies in the S&P beat earnings. That is that's strong strong that a lot of times we see markets move on a couple of companies, right? the fang companies, all that said, we, you know, we had these companies that were driving it up. But if 85% are, there's something to really be said to the strength on what's on what's going on there. And even if people believe there's some sort of pullback, it doesn't point to a like a real bear, like a protracted bear. It points to the market always has pullbacks and we always forget about them. I mean, heck, there's been a bunch of them in the last three or four years, like a bunch of them that we don't even feel anymore.

Um, but right now, those earning numbers are exciting. And it means it's not just driven by tech companies. It's not just driven by AI. Like right now, as we go into the third quarter, across the board, the companies are performing pretty strongly. >> Yeah, they they are. And it is, you know, it is still there are the winners, the Mag Seven, there are a lot of, you know, they are a huge part of the market cap. So, what they do is just going to drive a big chunk of the S&P's performance. However, there's a lot of different stuff, right? Um, there are plenty of other companies in the S&P 500 who are not at their all-time highs that might be 10% or more off their all-time high for that one specific stock. And that just shows that like the market is not all overly enthusiastic and not all going in one direction. Um there's certainly some froth in certain areas and um we were talking we're we're going to do an episode on the AI market, the AI ecosystem, the is it in a bubble, all that stuff. We'll we'll get to it. Um it's not going anywhere uh this week or next week. So we got time, >> but um yeah, it is we want to see a broader rally and there's a couple things that I think are important here.

Number one, just international has done well. That is good in and of itself, right? And we believe in diversification. We don't want to be just concentrated in US tech. So that means we do own companies outside the US. We do own some mid and small companies. And guess what? Mid and small have not have underperformed the AI tech sector. Absolutely. However, it's also still good to own them because if we're worried about the concentration in that in that specific sector in the US, well, we own other stuff than just that one thing. So, in the big picture, there's some stuff that has room to continue to catch up in small caps, midcaps, international value stocks, uh that as rates ease, they're actually going to do a little bit better. um because they you know it doesn't matter for Microsoft and Apple and Amazon if rates are a quarter point lower or you know through a rate cutting cycle 1% or one and a half% lower but it sure does to a small cap that's cost of borrowing is pretty high.

>> Yeah, there's an irony you know I can't help but smile a little bit. Um, most people and most of our clients, fact, I'd say all of our clients, but most people who get professional advice, they really do want to be invested in a lot of things because they've achieved a certain amount of wealth and and that wealth is in context of their lives, right? So, some people may supposedly have less wealth, but they're very wealthy in their life because of how they have kind of structured things, right? And when they're coming to folks like us and other firms like us, it is really about how do you protect while you grow, right? Versus just grow. So, ironically, a lot of the people filing the hot dot are not people getting professional advice. And that's why it is important. We know these things go in cycles and when they talk about, you know, the AI bubble and like you said, we'll do a session on that in a few weeks. Um there'll be we just know there'll be some massive winners and losers in that because that's whatever happens when you create a new category.

Um everybody looks like they're winning and when they get to the finish line there's some massive winners and some massive losers. So we'll pull back for that. But um pivoting a little bit here, right? So, we've talked about the shutdown and we've talked about earnings and one of the things that just kind of out there floating right now is the kind of on and off again China deal and what's going on there and you know there's been some lot of noise and there's been it's actually promoted us to do some things too. I know I know you're a guy even with your military background that talks about some of the mineral rights deals and I saw we signed uh a pretty big deal with Australia. So talk a little bit about the China deal and maybe even how that's causing us to be a little bit more disciplined in the short term while not certainly not abandoning China and they're they're a long-term partner for us and we're a long-term partner for them. There's a lot of noise, but we need them and they need us.

>> Yeah. I mean the the last I don't know what 10 months uh has really just been two bulls beating their head against each other. um neither re, you know, realizing that neither one has the upper hand. We both got leverage. We both got pain points. And cooler heads have finally prevailed where all this oneupsmanship of you're going to restrict rare earths. Well, I'm going to hit you with 100% tariff. Well, blah blah blah. All that back and forth. It's calmed down, right? They finally met. They finally talked. Everybody realized, yeah, we want to buy stuff from you. You want to buy stuff from us. Okay, that's trade, right? And so they're making trade agreements. Um Scott Bessent, I think, is talking with them right now and kind of floated a pre-announcement, you know, before the formal thing is is fully baked. But the tariffs that were about to go on November 1st, those are delayed off, right? So that's off the table. That helped China back off their rare earth export controls, right? They were about to freeze rare earth to us and we're like, whoa, that's really like it's not an act of war, but it's it goes those things feed our war machine and so we care a lot about them.

>> It's aggressive. It's aggressive. >> It's aggressive. It is. Uh they've delayed that a year, right? That's not off the table, but it's delayed a year, which is good. Um, our farmers have have had not had a good year with basically like China stopped buying soybeans from us and said I think it was Argentina like they're just buying all the soybeans from Argentina. So our farmers their kind of marketplace dried up. They're trying to find other consumers of it. uh China agreed to restart that you know those purchases and do it for years to come which is good something you know they they decided something about fentanyl um you know China is notorious for exporting precursor chemicals to fentanyl if they help us with that that's great um I you know who knows how we actually enforce that uh and it doesn't go through the black market but that's good and then something about Tik Tok. I don't know.

Like this whole Tik Tok thing has been ridiculous to me. Uh but yeah, they're finalizing some kind of deal for US companies to run the US Tik Tok operation. >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Tik Tok's weird to me because I'm 58, so I got I got no play there, man. I mean, I'm on the the grams, the faces. I've seen all that. But, uh that's just something where I just think it's something where young people dance on it. I know it's more than that and I know people do a lot of commerce through it, but it's also why I think the whole country is not paying more attention to it because half of us are at an age where we're like, I don't even know what you're talking about. That's where my kid or in my case grandkids would be like doing some crazy dance. Um I will say you know with respect to China we should always expect this like like Xi and not just Trump no US president is going to show acquiescence publicly and Xi's not going to show acquiescence publicly. So I do think we're kind of getting used to it though. I think it's why the country or the markets don't overreact even the international markets when they get a little snippy at each other because again I think they need each other. I also think though that it is um if there's a silver lining to this and kind of the way this has come more to a head and I hope it doesn't end with this administration things like strategic reserves in these minerals that we have not had right like our our strategic reserve has always just been like oil and now it's like well we have plenty of that stuff here ourselves but we've never built up these things and I think it's causing us to be a little bit more disciplined um and I like I do like the strength that the administration's kind of taken on that stuff or again I think it's it they quickly went to Russia I mean uh Australia uh not Russia and uh and and signed a deal to do these kind of things. So I I believe that'll give us some leverage in the future as well.

>> Yeah, it's like technology is so unbelievably complex with all the different components and minerals and materials that go into these things. um or even I I saw this um kind of presentation talking about all the companies that are involved in making an Nvidia chip and it it goes all the way back to somewhere somebody's digging minerals out of the ground. Um it was actually there's a North Carolina company who provides almost all this the pure quartz that goes into chips. Didn't know that. Um that's pretty cool. And then there's people like who make the mirrors that do the the chip lithography. It's crazy, right? So it's vulnerable though, right? And so that like all this whole ecosystem of technology is dependent on cooperation and when you throw, you know, a wrench in the gears, it can really mess things up. And we had a little bit of that year this year. And I think all sides are saying that's not great. Like if we're in the high-tech game, we don't have it all ourselves.

China doesn't have it all themselves. They're dependent on other people to do stuff. There was a funny report that um uh what is it? Uh ASML. So ASML makes these big old machines that then like produce the chips. Um, and they China bought one and took it apart and couldn't put put it back together correctly. So, they called ASML like to repair it. And they're like, "You guys were trying to reverse engineer this, weren't you?" And because they're they're trying to reverse engineer and and steal the technology and you and you know, be able to do that in country and they can't, right? this these people who build these things are extremely good at it and it's not easy to replicate. >> Yeah. You know, I saw the uh along those lines, I I saw an article where, you know, I saw one a few months ago where the Ford CEO like, you know, drove a EV made in China and was like, "Oh my god, it's the greatest thing I've ever we should be so worried." But then the Rivian CEO actually bought one, took it apart and said, "Yeah, it's really good, but it's not better than what's here." You know, this fascination on it being built for like they always build stuff cheaper over there.

>> Doesn't mean like no country's letting them sell it at the cost that you know that they're building over there and there's all these import exports. There's tariffs everywhere. We're not the only place that does this. But um it's interesting like you said we like they forever have stole IP and you can only re reverse engineer so much. I mean they everybody would rather just get the blueprint so to speak. So, >> so Matt, um I think we'll end on that today, but next week we're going to talk a little bit about real estate and our producer Chris, young man in his mid20s, actually had some questions about it because, you know, he like a lot of people at that age are looking at the housing market and things like interest rate and just cost. And when he asked us the question, it it caused me to just do a little looking around here in Winter Park, which is a great zip code, and houses usually turn over pretty quickly. Well, they're starting to sit on the market for four or five months. And in my lifetime, by the way, I've seen that a lot. In fact, I I owned a house once for an extra 13 months, and that stunk.

But four or five months used to be the norm. But now if you don't sell your house in like over the last five or six years, if you didn't sell your house in like 60 days, you were nervous and scared and uh >> and so we'll talk a little bit about what's the effect, what the slowdown is, what the Fed rates u mean going forward. So next time we're going to talk a little bit about real estate in general, including if I'm not mistaken, some of the institutional players that are getting in the housing market and is that really a big deal? I guess that's what we'll we'll talk about next time. >> Sounds good. >> Thanks, Matt. Um, for everybody again, you'll see uh info uh at trillium-wealth.com. And uh if you have any questions that you want to ask us, just put it in there. If you want to have a topic you want to talk about, put it in there. We've we've actually had a couple topics that were given to us by investors, and that would be our favorite thing to do.

So, if you're thinking of something, and as usual, we've had more people starting to share it. Um, share our information because we're here to educate. It's not a uh it's not a commercial. It's just a a thing where we go out here and educate investors on what's the real talk, the plain talk of what's going on out there. So, thanks, Matt. Look forward to doing this again in a couple weeks. >> Take care. >>

Next step

Start with a conversation.

Tell us what is on your mind. We will match you with an advisor near you, or meet by video.

Start a conversation